Water at the base of the tank or a gas smell comes first
If water is pooling under the heater, shut the cold-water valve on the pipe going into the top of the tank. Then cut the power or the gas: switch off the breaker for an electric heater, or turn the gas control knob to off on a gas unit. A leak from the tank body can't be repaired. The tank is finished, and the only question left is which replacement to fit.
If you smell gas near the heater, don't touch the light switches or the control knob. Leave the house and call your gas supplier's emergency line from outside. Call us about the heater once the gas supplier has made the line safe. If a supply pipe has burst or the valve won't stop a leak, call the emergency plumber.
A drip from the pressure relief valve on the side of the tank is a different problem. It can mean the tank is overheating or the water pressure in the house is too high. Never cap that valve. Put a bucket under the discharge pipe and have the valve checked.
No hot water usually traces to one part
On an electric heater, check the breaker first. If it has tripped and trips again when you reset it, leave it off. Most electric tanks have two elements and two thermostats. If one element fails, you get lukewarm water that runs out fast. If both fail, you get none. Both are parts that can be replaced.
On a gas heater, look through the small window near the bottom of the tank. If you see no flame, the pilot is out. Relight it by following the steps on the tank label. If it won't stay lit, the usual cause is the thermocouple or the gas valve. A venting fault can also shut the burner off. Don't keep relighting it; call us.
Check the date on the rating plate before you decide on a repair. Spending a lot to fix an old tank can be the wrong call. Where repair and replacement both make sense, you get a written price for each.
Hot water runs out faster in a Sydenham winter
Village water comes from Sydenham Lake. In winter, the raw water at the treatment plant has been as cold as 1 degree Celsius, so the water reaching your tank is close to freezing. The heater has to warm that water further, so it takes longer to refill with hot water between showers. A tank that kept up in September can fall short in February with nothing wrong with it.
Before you call, note when the hot water runs out: after one shower or after three, and in winter only or all year. If it falls short only in the cold months, the heater is usually working and is too small. If it falls short all year, or got worse suddenly, something has failed: an element, the dip tube or the sediment layer.
Houses in Harrowsmith, Inverary, Perth Road and Battersea draw from private wells, so the lake figure doesn't apply there. The plumber measures the incoming water temperature at the cold tap before sizing a replacement.
Rumbling, rusty water and a bad smell come from inside the tank
Sydenham's village water is marginally hard, with an average hardness of 134 mg/l. Hard water leaves scale, and the scale settles on the bottom of the tank. Rumbling or popping when the burner or element runs is water boiling under that layer. Draining and flushing helps on a tank that isn't too far gone. On an old tank, flushing can stir up sediment that then blocks the drain valve, so ask before you try it.
If the hot water comes out rusty and the cold runs clear, the anode rod is used up or the tank lining is failing. A rotten-egg smell from the hot water only usually comes from the anode rod reacting with the water. Pulling the rod shows which problem you have. If the tank itself is rusting through, replacing it is the only fix. Leaking fixtures and worn valves elsewhere in the house are covered under plumbing repairs.
A replacement is sized for winter water, not the old label
Tank or tankless, electric or gas, the size comes from two things: how your household uses hot water and the coldest water the heater will see. A tank is sized on how much hot water you use in your busiest hour. A tankless unit is sized on flow: how many taps and showers run at once, and how much it has to warm the water. With winter water near freezing, a tankless heater that looks big enough on paper can give less flow in February than you expect.
Electric or gas depends on what the house already has. Going from electric to gas needs a gas line and a vent. Going from gas to electric needs enough electrical capacity. You'll know what the change involves before you choose.
Register the new heater with the manufacturer to keep the manufacturer's warranty, and keep the receipt with your house papers. Replacing a water heater is plumbing work, and plumbing work can need a building permit. The township building department decides whether yours does.
How a water heater visit goes
The plumber checks the power or gas supply, the controls, the relief valve and, on a gas unit, the venting. Then you're told what has failed. You approve a written price for the repair or the replacement before any part is fitted. Our pricing guide explains how that price is put together.
On installation, the temperature is set high enough to keep the tank healthy and low enough to keep the taps safe. Ontario's Building Code limits water from a shower head or into a bathtub to 49 degrees Celsius. If the tank runs hotter than that, a mixing valve brings the temperature down at the outlet.
Work is performed by licensed plumbers (306A Certificate of Qualification). Gas water heaters come under Ontario Regulation 212/01, which says a registered contractor must install and service them. Gas work is performed by TSSA-certified gas technicians. To book, send us the details or ask for a written quote. A photo of the rating plate helps.
